Maundy Thursday, Year B, April 1, 2021
Exodus 12:1-14,
Psalm 116:1-2, 12-19,
1 Corinthians 11:23-26,
John 13:1-17, 31b-35
Preached by Pastor Anna C. Haugen, Chinook and Naselle Lutheran Churches, WA
May the words of my mouth and the meditations of my heart be acceptable in your sight, O Lord.
Grace and peace to you from God our Father, and the Lord Jesus Christ.
Our Gospel reading has a chunk taken out of the middle of it. This is done for practical reasons; the Gospel of John is very, very long, and there are often times when a whole story is simply too long to read in worship in its entirety. In the Gospel of John, the Last Supper takes up five whole chapters, not including Jesus’ arrest in the Garden of Gethsemane. So we condense, we take the important parts, and leave the rest of the story for other worship services and Bible studies. We’ll hear more from Jesus’ Maundy Thursday message in Easter and at Pentecost. But tonight, we focus in on two things: the foot-washing, when Jesus washed his disciples’ feet, and the commandment to love one another. After all, the commandment to love one another is what the day is named for. “Maundy” comes from the Latin word “Mandatum,” which means commandment. Jesus commands us to love one another.
The thing is, Judas Iscariot, the one who betrayed Jesus? He’s included in the footwashing. He’s there, and Jesus knows that he is about to betray him. He gets his feet washed, and Jesus tells him to leave, and night falls, and then Jesus tells his disciples to love one another. Knowing that one of them is a traitor, knowing that one of them has left their fellowship, knowing that death is going to result from Judas’ choices, Jesus still tells his followers to love one another. Jesus doesn’t say “love one another, except for Judas, that rat.” Jesus doesn’t say “love one another, except for enemies and people who betray you.” Jesus says ‘I give you a new commandment, that you love one another. Just as I have loved you, you also should love one another. By this everyone will know that you are my disciples, if you have love for one another.’
And Jesus doesn’t mean just saying they love others, either; Jesus expects them to put that love into action. Jesus gave them an example of what that love looks like when he washed their feet. It’s a love that means that when you see something you can do to help people, you do it. Even when it’s kinda icky, like washing feet. Loving is not just a think you feel, it’s a thing you do. And Jesus, crucially, tells them to love as he has loved them. Jesus loves them enough to empty himself of pride and wash their feet. Jesus loves them enough to be born in human flesh and become truly human. Jesus loves them enough to suffer and die for them.
And, crucially, Judas is included in that love. Judas does something terrible, something evil. Judas knowingly chooses to leave the community and align himself with their enemies. Judas knowingly participates in the machineries of an unjust and cruel empire. Jesus knows that this is wrong, Jesus says that Judas is wrong. This is not a case of pretending Judas’ actions don’t matter, or sweeping them under the rug, or excusing them. Judas was wrong, period, end of story, and there will be consequences for him and for everyone else. And Judas still gets his feet washed like everyone else. Judas is still part of Jesus’ love … and if the disciples are supposed to love as Jesus does, that means the disciples are supposed to love Judas, too.
What does it mean to love your enemies? What does it mean to love people who have hurt you, betrayed you? To love people who still have the power to hurt and betray you, people who have not repented, as Judas has not yet repented at this point? A lot of times when people say we should love or forgive those who hurt us, what they really mean is that we should allow those people to keep hurting us, or we should just sweep their bad deeds under the rug and pretend it never happened. That is not what Jesus is commanding, here. Judas is wrong, tragically wrong, and it is a deep and total betrayal. Jesus isn’t excusing his actions. But at the same time, Judas is part of the sinful world Jesus has come to redeem.
This is a hard thing for us to grasp. How do we love people who have genuinely done bad things? How do we love people who have hurt us? How do we hold people accountable while loving them? How do we put that love into action in a world which is more prone to hatred and violence and retaliation than to love?
Jesus came to save the cosmos, to save all people. Jesus came that we might have life, and have it abundantly. Jesus came to usher in the kingdom, to show us what life in God is like. God is love; God is truth; God is justice and mercy both. God is a peace that the world can’t give and doesn’t understand. And my God, the world needs that peace, now more than ever. And the way we get that peace, the way we participate in the kingdom of heaven, the way we live out the salvation that is Jesus’ gift to us, is to love one another as Jesus loved us.
The human instinct when we are hurt is to lash out, to take our pain out on other people, to hurt people as we have been hurt. To hurt people more than they have hurt us. To respond to pain by making more of it. But that will not bring in God’s kingdom. That won’t bring the peace and justice and mercy of God. That won’t give us abundant life. You can’t hurt people into being better; you can’t punish people into making the right choices. Fear of punishment won’t make people good and it won’t make the world a better place. The only thing that will do that is love. Love of God; love of neighbor. Love that looks all the evil in the world straight in the face and says “You do not get a free pass, and you don’t get to rule me, and I am not going to react to you by becoming like you. I am not going to hurt you as you have hurt me. I am going to make a better choice; I am going to make the choice that Jesus commands us to make. I am going to love even when it is hard; I am going to choose to participate in the healing of the world rather than in making more hurt.”
That choice is not easy. And it looks different in different circumstances. You can’t just choose to love someone by rote; you can’t just make the choice once and then never think about it again. You have to ask the question constantly and consistently: what is the loving response to this? How do I love this person even when I don’t want to? How do we receive the blessing of God’s love in Christ Jesus, and then love one another so that the whole world can see it and be transformed by it?
May God fill us with his love, and may we live out that love so that all the world will know that we are his disciples.
Amen.